Parshat Shoftim: A Murder Mystery in the Field

Parashat Shoftim closes with a murder mystery: a corpse is discovered in a field, and no one seems to know what transpired or who is culpable. The Torah responds with a strange public ritual: the elders of the city nearest to the corpse must perform the eglah arufah - the “axed heifer” - as a means of communal atonement and a plea for forgiveness on behalf of the Jewish people amidst this tragedy. “All of the elders of that city, who are nearest to the corpse, shall wash their hands over the heifer that was axed in the valley. And they shall make this declaration: ‘Our hands did not shed this blood, nor did our eyes see it done.’” (Devarim 21:6-7) Certainly no one suspects these saintly leaders of being the culprits themselves! Why, then, must they stand over the heifer and publicly declare their innocence? 

The Sages locate the elders’ possible culpability not in the field, but at the city gates: Had this traveler passed through their town hungry, thirsty, and alone? Our tradition teaches that there is a great mitzvah to escort guests, so that no harm should befall them on their way. As the Talmud (Sotah 46b) explains, these elders are effectively saying, “The victim did not come our way, for had he done so, we surely would have given him provisions for his journey. We did not see him at all, for had we done so, we certainly would have provided him with an escort to his destination.” Rabbi Meir goes further: the obligation to accompany someone is so great that one must do so even against one’s own will, as the reward for accompaniment is beyond measure. And Rabbi Yochanan, in the name of Rabbi Meir, adds that one who does not accompany another, or does not allow himself to be accompanied, is like one who spills blood, bearing responsibility for any injury or, God forbid, death that might occur as a result of their inaction. The elders are not merely denying that they committed the murder. They are publicly stating that they did not fail this stranger before he ever reached the field. They simply had no chance to help. 

When we passively wait for our fellow Jews to come to us seeking community, we miss countless opportunities to accompany them to their destination, whether physical, emotional, or spiritual. What would it look like if—instead of sitting at the proverbial city gates waiting for travelers to pass by—we all saw ourselves as leaders, as elders, as people of agency, and took upon ourselves the initiative to go out into the field and find those who are lost, estranged, and otherwise in need of sustenance and protection? Perhaps then, we would have no need to wash our hands clean of other people who are “just passing through.” Perhaps, as the Maharal of Prague (Rabbi Yehuda Loew, 1524-1609) suggests, if we were to cultivate such solidarity toward our fellow Jews, proactively surrounding them with community, we would not only have physical accountability for each other but also merit the kind of Divine protection that would preclude the occurrence of such tragedies. May we all have the wherewithal to notice those around us, the alacrity to anticipate others’ needs, and the strength to make room in our hearts for those that pass through them.

—

Welcome to Torah in Harlem! As we move through each week, we’ll explore the stories and insights of the weekly Torah portion—the ancient text at the heart of Jewish life—and let them inspire conversation in our community. Our hope is to cultivate a gathering place where learning belongs, reflection brings joy, and we can all grow together. Want to hop into the conversation? Join our Torah in Harlem Whatsapp Group.

Artwork by Hillel Smith.